AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

Books like…

Shutter Island cover

Books Like Shutter Island

by Dennis Lehane · about this book

Loved Shutter Island by Dennis Lehane? If its twisty, psychological thriller and male lead hooked you, these 20 books hit the same notes — starting with Sharp Objects, I Let You Go and Night Film. Every pick is matched by what’s actually inside the book, not just its genre, and we skip other books by the same author so you find someone new.

What’s inside Shutter Island: Twisty · Psychological Thriller · Male Lead · Asylum · Thriller

  1. Sharp Objects cover

    Sharp Objects

    Gillian Flynn

    Psychological Thriller · Twisty · Unreliable Narrator · Missing Person · PTSD

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  2. I Let You Go cover

    I Let You Go

    Clare Mackintosh

    Twisty · Psychological Thriller · Unreliable Narrator · Law Enforcement · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  3. Night Film cover

    Night Film

    Marisha Pessl

    Twisty · Missing Person · Unreliable Narrator · Psychological Thriller · Atmospheric

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  4. A Flicker in the Dark cover

    A Flicker in the Dark

    Stacy Willingham

    Psychological Thriller · Twisty · Unreliable Narrator · Missing Person · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  5. Fool Me Once cover

    Fool Me Once

    Harlan Coben

    PTSD · Twisty · Psychological Thriller · Tense and Suspenseful · Unreliable Narrator

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  6. The Silence of the Lambs cover

    The Silence of the Lambs

    Thomas Harris

    Psychological Thriller · Asylum · Detective Protagonist · Missing Person · Twisty

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  7. The Snowman cover

    The Snowman

    Jo Nesbo

    Twisty · Law Enforcement · Detective Protagonist · Missing Person · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  8. The Widow cover

    The Widow

    Fiona Barton

    Psychological Thriller · Unreliable Narrator · Missing Person · Twisty · Detective Protagonist

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  9. The Woman in the Window cover

    The Woman in the Window

    A.J. Finn

    Psychological Thriller · Unreliable Narrator · Twisty · PTSD · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  10. The Girl on the Train cover

    The Girl on the Train

    Paula Hawkins

    Psychological Thriller · Unreliable Narrator · Twisty · Missing Person · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  11. The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest cover

    The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest

    Stieg Larsson

    Asylum · Law Enforcement · Tense and Suspenseful · Cold War Era · Twisty

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  12. The House Across the Lake cover

    The House Across the Lake

    Riley Sager

    Twisty · Psychological Thriller · Unreliable Narrator · Missing Person · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  13. Death Note, Vol. 1: Boredom cover

    Death Note, Vol. 1: Boredom

    Tsugumi Ohba

    Psychological Thriller · Twisty · Law Enforcement · Detective Protagonist · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  14. Gorky Park cover

    Gorky Park

    Martin Cruz Smith

    Law Enforcement · Cold War Era · Detective Protagonist · Conspiracy · Atmospheric

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  15. Pines cover

    Pines

    Blake Crouch

    Twisty · Missing Person · Law Enforcement · Tense and Suspenseful · Thriller

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  16. Never Lie cover

    Never Lie

    Freida McFadden

    Psychological Thriller · Twisty · Missing Person · Unreliable Narrator · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  17. The Evolution of Mara Dyer cover

    The Evolution of Mara Dyer

    Michelle Hodkin

    PTSD · Unreliable Narrator · Psychological Thriller · Asylum · Twisty

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  18. Goodnight Beautiful cover

    Goodnight Beautiful

    Aimee Molloy

    Psychological Thriller · Twisty · Unreliable Narrator · Missing Person · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  19. The Good Girl cover

    The Good Girl

    Mary Kubica

    Psychological Thriller · Twisty · Missing Person · Unreliable Narrator · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla
  20. Child 44 cover

    Child 44

    Tom Rob Smith

    Law Enforcement · Detective Protagonist · Cold War Era · Conspiracy · Tense and Suspenseful

    Buy Libby Hoopla