Books like…
Loved The Paying Guests by Sarah Waters? If its historical fiction, literary fiction and mystery hooked you, these 20 books hit the same notes — starting with The Blind Assassin, Girl with a Pearl Earring and The Age of Innocence. Every pick is matched by what’s actually inside the book, not just its genre, and we skip other books by the same author so you find someone new.
What’s inside The Paying Guests: Historical Fiction · Literary Fiction · Mystery · London · LGBTQ+ Protagonist
Margaret Atwood
Roaring Twenties · Secret Relationship · Forbidden Love · Atmospheric · Character-Driven
Tracy Chevalier
Secret Relationship · Slow Burn Romance · Forbidden Love · Atmospheric · Historical Fiction
Edith Wharton
Secret Relationship · Slow Burn Romance · Atmospheric · Literary Fiction · Forbidden Love
Natasha Pulley
Slow Burn Romance · Forbidden Love · Atmospheric · Character-Driven · London
Hillary Jordan
Secret Relationship · Forbidden Love · Literary Fiction · Atmospheric · Character-Driven
Kiran Millwood Hargrave
Secret Relationship · Forbidden Love · London · Literary Fiction · Character-Driven
Ellis Avery
Roaring Twenties · Forbidden Love · Atmospheric · Character-Driven · LGBTQ+ Protagonist
Anita Shreve
Secret Relationship · Slow Burn Romance · Forbidden Love · Atmospheric · Historical Fiction
Evelyn Waugh
Roaring Twenties · Forbidden Love · Literary Fiction · LGBTQ+ Protagonist · Historical Fiction
Jessie Burton
Secret Relationship · Forbidden Love · Character-Driven · Atmospheric · Historical Fiction
Amal El-Mohtar
Secret Relationship · Slow Burn Romance · Forbidden Love · Atmospheric · LGBTQ+ Protagonist
Susanna Kearsley
Secret Relationship · Slow Burn Romance · Forbidden Love · Character-Driven · Historical Fiction
Kate Morton
Roaring Twenties · Forbidden Love · Atmospheric · Character-Driven · Historical Fiction
Taylor Jenkins Reid
Secret Relationship · Slow Burn Romance · Forbidden Love · Character-Driven · Historical Fiction
Jeanette Winterson
Secret Relationship · Forbidden Love · Literary Fiction · Atmospheric · LGBTQ+ Protagonist
Arthur Golden
Slow Burn Romance · Forbidden Love · Atmospheric · Character-Driven · Literary Fiction
Courtney Milan
Secret Relationship · Slow Burn Romance · Character-Driven · London · Historical Fiction
V E Schwab
Forbidden Love · London · Atmospheric · Character-Driven · LGBTQ+ Protagonist
Kate Chopin
Secret Relationship · Forbidden Love · Atmospheric · Literary Fiction · Character-Driven
A.S. Byatt
Secret Relationship · Forbidden Love · Literary Fiction · Character-Driven · Historical Fiction
More “books like” lists
Books like Hide and Seek Books like Silas Marner Books like The Body Farm Books like The Boy Next Door Books like Alexander Hamilton Books like Galápagos Books like The Sun Is Also a Star Books like Beyond the Highland Mist